Comparison
Traily vs Edgewonk
Edgewonk has been doing serious trade analytics for over a decade and takes psychology more seriously than most. Traily comes at the same problem from the other end of the trade.
| Traily | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Records every trade with instrument, strategy, direction, entry, exit, stop, target and size | Yes | Yes |
| Screenshots, notes and tags on a trade | Yes, up to eight shots before and after | Yes |
| Analytics: win rate, expectancy, profit factor, runs, excursion | Yes | Yes |
| Imports a CSV from any broker | Yes, including order logs matched into round trips | Yes |
| Records whether you followed your own rules on each trade | Yes, as a pre-trade checklist with three verdicts | Mistake tracking and trade checklists, reviewed after the trade |
| Streak and day colours decided by rule adherence | Yes | No equivalent |
| Psychology and emotion analysis | Yes, tied to the feeling you logged before you entered | Yes, a dedicated psychology module |
| Accountability buddy or team who sees discipline only | Yes | No |
| Runs on a phone | Yes, web plus iOS and Android | Desktop focused |
| Price | Free while we build it | Paid, with a refund window they publish |
Checked on their public site in September 2026. If something here is out of date, tell us and we will fix it.
The real difference
Before the trade, or after it.
Edgewonk is excellent at telling you, on Sunday, what went wrong on Wednesday. That is worth a lot, and Traily does a version of it too.
But a review can only ever describe. The moment that decides the week is the thirty seconds before you click, when you are annoyed about the last stop out and the setup in front of you is almost good enough. Traily puts the checklist there.
Choose Edgewonk if
You want the deepest possible post-trade analysis, you work at a desk, and you would rather pay once than depend on something that is still being built.
Choose Traily if
You already know your leaks and you keep walking into them anyway, you want the intervention at the moment of the decision, and you want somebody else to be able to see whether you are keeping your word.
Questions
Edgewonk is a one-off purchase. Traily is free. What is the catch?
There is no catch today and we will not invent one. Traily is free while we are building it, everything included. When there is a paid plan we will say so on the pricing page first, and we will not remove what you already rely on without telling you.
Edgewonk has a psychology module. Is that not the same thing?
It is the closest thing in the category, and it is genuinely good. The difference is when it happens. Edgewonk analyses how you felt and what you did after the fact. Traily puts the checklist in front of the trade, so the verdict exists before the result does.
Put the checklist in front of the trade.
Free while we build it. Import your history, and start gating tomorrow morning.
Free while we build it. No card, no download, no broker connection.